Skip navigation.

What Best Practices really are. -- CIO Article

context-driven testing | development methodology | ethics | general software testing | metaphors | other online resources | people issues | perspectives | test management
Of all the places I expected to find an article supporting the fact that Best Practices is nothing more than a square on someone's buzz-word bingo card, CIO wasn't it. The highlights are these...
Using celebs for endorsements has become such best practice that everyone does it. So what is best practice about it? Nothing. The phrase is simply a demonstration of how cliched business language dresses up the concept of copying something someone else has done. And when lots of companies copy the copier, it becomes dull, intellectually stagnant and offers no competitive advantage. It's just a me-too strategy executed by the cynical, the lazy, or the lazy cynics.
and...
In the world of technology, the phrase best practice makes my blood boil. Those on the vendor side sell it as if it is the elixir of life, a golden key to the city of hi-tech paradise. The buyer-side of the equation is little better. You know you are dealing with a room deficient in imagination and innovation genes when someone asks: "What's best practice?"
and my favorite...
...you need to get out the crucifix, garlic cloves and wooden stake when you come across peers posting up their successful projects as best practice.
You can read the article by Mark Hollands here. If you don't have time to read the whole thing, it closes as follows (*note* spoiler alert):
If everyone ran their technology departments the same way and conducted projects in an identical manner, then best practice would have its place. Life is not like that. Those who believe it is, face an existence in which imitation drives you closer to the abyss of commoditization. This is why the smart guys lead the way, thinking innovatively and committing to creativity. You don't want to be a carbon copy of your competitor. You want to innovate. Be original. Be the best.

That's because "best practice

That's because "best practice" is a (crappy) marketing term used by insecure consultants. At least in my experience.

--
Scott Barber
Chief Technologist, PerfTestPlus
Executive Director, Association for Software Testing
sbarber@perftestplus.com

Thanks Scott!

I did a search for "best practices" on the CIO web site. There were too many results trumpeting "best" practices for any of them to claim to be the best. However, I did encounter an interesting column titled "Worst Practice" that contains the following:
Best practice isn't. Best practice is a fiction, a lie and a con job that has ruined the credibility and reputation of many good CIOs. CIOs should never, ever allow their IT investments to be determined by anyone else's best practices. Instead, CIOs should find ways to creatively challenge every effort made to import best practice transformations into their company. Why? Because even the most brilliant analysis of a best practice has virtually nothing to do with the ultimate effectiveness or impact of its implementation.
Ben

Thanks for posting this

because that's right, when someone asks "what's the best practice", it does mean they don't have any ideas they consider "good" themselves...

Incidentally, and though this is from my perspective in the midwest, when I've worked at software development companies, I've never heard anyone say "best practice". I have heard people say "best practice" in IT shops. And you hear it even more, much more, when there are a lot of "consultants" around... (meaning the so-called consultants, not the real ones).

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click 'Save settings' to activate your changes.